Why Quality is Better Than Quantity in Email Marketing
The email marketing audience often doesn’t get the attention it deserves.
Many focus on subscriber count but overlook who is actually on the list and what they care about.
Understanding your audience and what they find valuable is the foundation of successful email marketing.
When you know who your subscribers are, what challenges they face, and what interests them, you can craft emails that truly resonate.
Instead of just another message in their inbox, your emails become something they look forward to. And when your audience feels like you’re speaking directly to them, they’re more likely to open and read.
You build trust and strong relationships when you provide them helpful tips, exclusive offers, or the fun behind the scenes.
Email marketing isn’t just about promoting your business, products, or services, it’s about creating a true, loyal connection.
A Little Story About Knowing Your Audience
A while ago, someone gifted me a very bright pink T‑shirt with some bling. The shirt screamed cotton candy dance party, but here’s the catch: I’m not a fan of pink. Not even close.
There’s nothing wrong with the shirt itself, it might be perfect for someone else. But for me? It didn’t fit at all. I felt like I’d joined a glittery clown circus. I am a neutrals girl; black, gray, white, and maybe taupe when I feel wild. That pink shirt lived in my closet for years, tags still attached, because it simply wasn’t me.
That’s exactly what happens when you send emails without knowing your audience. Even the best‑intentioned, well‑designed message can miss the mark if it doesn’t align with the people you’re 'talking' to. Instead of sparking excitement, your email ends up unopened, like that T‑shirt, destined for the donation bin.
So how can you know your audience?
How to Know Your Email Audience
One of the best ways to understand your audience is to simply ask them.
Send out a quick survey or poll to learn what topics they’re most interested in. Even a short email asking what they’d love to hear more about can provide great insight.
Beyond that, pay attention to what your customers and clients are already telling you.
What questions do they ask when interacting with your business?
What challenges do they mention?
Use real conversations to guide your email content.
Email analytics also provide valuable clues.
You can look at what subject lines get the most opens, which links are clicked, and what content brings engagement. By tracking what appeals to your audience, you can create a more effective email strategy.
The key to successful email marketing is listening, both through direct feedback and data.
When you truly understand your audience, you can send emails that feel relevant, personal, and worth opening.
Quality over Quantity: Why It Matters
A strong email marketing audience isn’t just about having a big list, it’s about having the right people on that list.
Your goal is to attract and keep subscribers who truly care about what you have to say, offer, or sell.
Your target audience is what truly matters, they are your VIP list in business, the contacts who value what you offer.
The number of subscribers doesn’t define success; having the right subscribers does.
And if people unsubscribe? That’s actually a good thing!
It means they were not your ideal audience, and their exit makes room for those who truly want to be there – I talk more about loving the unsubscribe in THIS blog post!
An engaged email list is far more powerful than a big one full of people who aren’t interested.
Let’s say you own a boutique that sells holiday-themed gift boxes. Someone signs up for your email list in November to grab a special discount on a Christmas gift. They make their purchase, enjoy their order, and by January, they unsubscribe.
At first, that might feel like a loss, but in reality, it makes sense. They were interested in a one-time holiday buy, not year-round shopping. And that’s okay! They got value from your emails when they needed it, and now they’re making space for subscribers who do want to hear from you regularly.
It’s not about keeping everyone, it’s about keeping the right ones.
When you focus on quality over quantity, your email marketing will be more effective and enjoyable, for both you and your subscribers.
7 Ways to Build and Maintain a Quality Email Audience
So, how exactly can you go about building and maintaining a QUALITY email audience? There are a few simple key strategies you can use!
- Attract the Right People
Make sure your sign-up forms, lead magnets, and social promotions speak directly to your ideal audience. If you are offering a freebie, discount, or exclusive content for email sign-ups, make sure it aligns with the interests of the people
you
actually
want to be on your list.
- Be Clear About What They’re Signing Up For
If someone subscribes expecting weekly tips but gets daily sales emails instead, they’ll unsubscribe fast. Set expectations upfront, and let them know what they are getting.
- Use Segmentation
Not every subscriber has the same needs. Grouping your audience by interests allows you to send targeted emails that feel more personal and valuable, and keep engagement high.
- Provide Value Consistently
If every email is just a sales pitch, people will tune out. Share useful tips, behind-the-scenes content, or personal stories that connect with your audience.
- Keep It Personal
Use names, customize content based on their interests, and write like you’re talking 1:1 to a friend.
- Clean Your List Regularly
It’s better to have a smaller, engaged list than a large one full of inactive subscribers who never open your emails. Remove unengaged contacts and focus on those who are active on your list.
- Consistency Builds Trust
Sending emails regularly keeps you ‘front and center’. If you go months without emailing, your audience may forget about you, leading to lower engagement.
You Own Your Email List, So Know Who’s on It
Your email list isn’t just a collection of names and emails, it’s a powerful business asset that you own.
Unlike social media, where you are in ‘rented’ space and the algorithms control your reach, your email list is something you have more control over.
Building a strong email audience means you always have a direct line to your most interested customers and clients, no matter what happens on other platforms.
By understanding your audience, delivering valuable content, and increasing your connections, you build a loyal, engaged community that supports your business.
Remember, focus on quality over quantity, embrace unsubscribes as a positive thing, and keep showing up with content that matters.
If you can use some help with email marketing and growing an audience, click HERE.
We can create a plan that works for you. 🖤
________
Want to explore more topics about email marketing? Check out these blog posts below and dive into some good email tips, strategies, and helpful to-do's to help grow not only your email marketing but also your business.
Email Marketing Blog Posts
- Why Email Marketing is a Must for Small Business Growth
- How to Get Started with Email Marketing
- Email Marketing Content: What Do You Even Say?
- Looking for more content ideas? Click the graphic below for a FREE content list with 21 prompts to help you keep the content flowing.
I'm Brady.
I'm a
small biz virtual assistant, specializing in helping you stay on top of your day-to-day tasks.
HERE'S HOW I CAN HELP.
